Are Carbs Bad?
Updated: Apr 22, 2021
I want to shout if from the hilltops. Carbohydrates, commonly known as “carbs”, are not bad for you! In fact, they are the fuel your body runs on. Carbohydrates are converted to glucose during digestion and that glucose is the energy source for our muscles. Without glucose our muscles can’t work. Without carbohydrates your body will begin to literally consume itself in order to make glucose. This is why the keto diet is so popular. Without the carbs in the diet the body begins to use up the fat stores in order to make glucose but it also will use protein - yes, protein taken from wherever it can get it - our muscles and bones particularly, to make glucose. In the short term, the keto dieter will lose weight, but there’s a steep price to pay (see “The Dangers of the Keto Diet”).
Not only are carbohydrates essential for proper functioning of the muscles, but are also essential to our brain, kidneys and heart function. Carbs are also essential for protein synthesis and proper digestive health. The longest living populations on earth eat a high-carb diet.
The Type of Carb Matters
We must make a distinction here between complex carbohydrates found in plants and refined carbohydrates. Complex carbohydrates include fruits, vegetables, and whole grains and contain many nutrients found only in plants such as phytochemical and fiber. Refined carbohydrates are made by a manufacturing process that strips out most or all of the starch, fiber, vitamins, minerals, phytochemical and often adds in fat in the form of trans fat. Refined carbohydrates are consistently associated with higher body weight and chronic disease whereas complex carbohydrates from plants are consistently associated with lower body weight and lack of disease. Here are some
examples of each:
Complex Carbohydrates: whole fruits and vegetables such as apples, bananas, corn, broccoli along with whole grains such as oats, brown rice, millet, barley, and legumes such as kidney beans, black beans and lentils.
Refined Carbohydrates: cake, donuts, pastries, candy, potato chips, pretzels, white rice and most commercially produced breads and crackers. It is simply not true that all carbohydrates induce weight gain. Says researcher, Linda Van Horn, PhD, of Northwestern University, "without exception, a high-complex-carbohydrate, high-vegetable-protein diet is associated with low body mass. High-protein diets were associated with higher body weight.”
The Dangers of the Keto Diet (and other low-carb diets) The ketogenic diet (“keto”) is the latest in a long line of low-carbohydrate, higher-protein, high-fat diets. These diets - including Atkins, South Beach, paleo, primal, and keto - all promote moderate to high protein intake from animal sources and some level of carbohydrate reduction. The most severe of the carb reductions is the keto diet which advocates a high intake of fat and only 5% of calories from carbs. Without the glucose from carbs, the body extracts energy from fats consumed in the diet, which creates ketone bodies as a byproduct of metabolizing fats. No human population has survived in a perpetual state of “ketosis”. Side effects include: kidney stones, fatal cardiac arrhythmias, pancreatitis, higher cholesterol level among others. “Recently, researchers at Harvard decided to look at 100,000 people: 'Low-Carb Diets and All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality.' They found that low-carb diets were associated with higher all-cause mortality, higher cardiovascular disease mortality, and higher cancer mortality. The final nail in Atkins’ coffin. Men and women on low-carb diets lead significantly shorter lives; more cancer deaths, more heart attacks." (source here).
The Ideal Whole Foods, Plant-Based Diet
The ideal whole-food, plant- based (WFPB) diet is about 75% carbohydrates. Some sources, including Dr. T, Colin Campbell of the Center for Nutritional Studies advocate for a diet of 80% carbs, 10% protein, and 10% fat.
Check out these resources if you want to learn more about the importance of carbohydrates and a whole foods plant based diet: